Interview with Anja Mihr – on Transitional Justice, Democratization and Challenges of Post-conflict Development

Petr Přibyla - 18. Prosinec 2011, rubrika Rozhovory

Témata: , ,

Why should amnesties be seen as the very last resort of any political decision to be taken in the transitional process? Which transitional justice mechanism is the most crucial to be imposed first in periods of the transition? What have we learned about transitional justice from the case of Spain after Franco’s death in 1975? Why does one of the reconciliation policies in Rwanda require former perpetrators who participated in Genocide to wash the bones and sculls of those they had killed in 1994?

Anja MihrThese questions were answered by Anja Mihr, Associate Professor at the Netherlands Institute of Human Rights, University of Utrecht (Netherlands), who is in her research focusing on transitional justice, reconciliation, human rights and democratization. Her work is mainly focused on transitional justice and reconciliation in Rwanda, Kosovo, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Germany, Chile, Spain and Somaliland.

 

Anja Mihr received her Ph.D in Political Sciences from the Free University in Berlin in 2001. Mihr has worked for Amnesty International and the German Institute for Human Rights. Starting as an assistant professor with UNESCO Chair in Human Rights at the University of Magdeburg in Germany in 2002, she later became a research director at the Humboldt University of Berlin, carrying out the research project „Teaching Human Rights in Europe“ from 2003–2006.

From 2002–2006 Anja Mihr also served as Chair of Amnesty International Germany. From 2006–2008, Anja was the European Programme Director for the European Master Degree in Human Rights and Democratization at the European Inter-University Center for Human Rights and Democratization (EIUC) in Venice, Italy. In 2008, Anja Mihr was Visiting Professor for Human Rights at Peking University Law School in China and worked for the Raoul Wallenberg Institute of Human Rights and Humanitarian Law.

“Strictly speaking, to apply transitional justice in processes of democratization is not about winners and losers, as such, but about strengthening democratic institutions.”

Is there an existing connection between transitional justice and democratization? That is to say, if transitional justice (TJ) is not fully implemented, will there be a negative impact on the process of democratization and furthermore on consolidation of a newly born democratic regime?

Transitional justice has both positive and negative effects on democratization processes. Positive effects include, for example, when citizens’ claims for transitional and/or criminal justice lead to governments having to react and respond by installing commissions of inquiry or initiating trials against perpetrators, etc. This level of responsiveness is one of the criteria to measure the quality of democracy. The assumption is that the more responsive governments are towards their citizens or victim groups’ needs, the more efficient democratic institutions are. Nevertheless, government responsiveness is only one side of the coin. At the same time, parliamentarian and legislative powers also have to be capable of restricting executive powers.

TJ measures can be indicators of how effectively democracy works, for example when the outcome or goals of these measures increase the civic trust of citizens in democratic institutions and thus strengthen the democratic regime. Governments are required to respond to the needs of people in transitional processes and democratization. If there are victim groups that suffered under previous regimes, they make claims for compensations, or for trial, etc. The government has to react to these claims. By responding to victim groups in this way, they government members experience democratic institutions – often for the first time in their lives. Executive and legislative powers should not suppress victim claims, and thus the government should take action within the framework of human rights’ norms and apply the rule of law. By doing so, civilians, civil society and governments learn about democracy. Human rights norms have an educative impact here.

For example, the government in transition countries can say that victim groups may want trials for every police officer in the country, but the government will conduct trials only for those police officers for which they have sufficient legal evidence to ground a prosecution. It is difficult in the first years after the end of a conflict or authoritarian regime to try and indict all potential perpetrators without even considering the lack of evidence and procedural mechanisms. But trials, whether domestic or international, can demonstrate what perpetrators can be held accountable for. At the same time, the perpetrators need a fair trial and also human rights’ standards have to be applied.

The negative effect of too many TJ mechanisms in too short time can lead to a radical reaction by citizens, old political elites and the dysfunction of new and yet still fragile democratic institutions. Some TJ mechanisms, for example memorial events and truth commissions, can open deep wounds or lead to arbitrary revenge. If names of perpetrators are made public through vetting without a proper indictment or a functioning independent judiciary in place that can uphold equity of rights, alleged perpetrators are without protection and may be subject to acts of vengeance. Family members of victims or victims themselves often take revenge without really knowing what precisely happened and considering to what extent someone had been involved in the previous regime or responsible for atrocities. Nevertheless, it is important to have a mix of TJ mechanisms and to respect the fact that some mechanisms might apply earlier than others, depending on the type of conflict, the severity of injustice and atrocities and how long oppression or war was going on.

Thus, sequencing and timing is important, too. It is also critical during this transition process, that the rule of law is applied and international human rights standards and law respected. Strictly speaking, to apply TJ in processes of democratization is not about winners and losers, as such, but about strengthening democratic institutions.

“There is also an argument, particularly often visible in Eastern Europe, that when people are taken to the court, old wounds will be opened. This is probably the basic argument you have against TJ.”

There are many core dimensions within transitional justice, e.g. criminal prosecutions, institutional reforms, restitution for the victims, truth commissions, etc. Which one would you say is the most crucial to impose first in periods of the transition? Otherwise, what far reaching negative consequences will result?

This is also connected to the question of when TJ can do harm to the democratization processes and hamper democratic institution building instead of supporting it. We should not expect countries in transition periods to imply all the TJ tools and mechanisms at once. For instance, maybe it is more adequate to have a trial against the former government, two, three or even ten years after the transition. I think what is crucial is that interim or elected governments acknowledge immediately after the regime change that atrocities and human rights abuses have happened in the past and that TJ measures will be applied to bring those responsible to justice at a later, more opportune time.

Governments and political elites have to be sensitive and responsive to the different needs and claims of their citizens. Not everybody in a society wants immediate trials. You need some time, and in these cases it can take a couple of years, even ten or twenty years, to really identify what kind of atrocities have happened. Taking the example of post WWII Germany, we have learned that there is no strict time limit on when and what TJ measures to apply. The important issue is that if there is a claim or a need to confront the past, democratic institutions ought to respond adequately in compliance with human rights and democratic standards. They can however install and initiate different mechanisms, but the important factor is, that they do not shy away from confronting the past.

In general, I would be careful with mass trials against the whole bureaucratic elite of the former regime. Needless to say that terror regimes and governments including dictators should be expelled immediately and be trialed – but here we talk about a rather small number of people – not necessarily the whole technocratic elite. It is better not to impose trials immediately after transition but as soon as possible. Governments should not wait twenty years. History commissions or lustration procedures can be an interim solution. They can investigate the alleged cases according to international human rights standards and the domestic law that was in place at the time the abuses, crimes against humanity or atrocities happened. In some cases it can take some years to have enough facts on the table before you can launch the trial.

There is also an argument, particularly often visible in Eastern Europe, that when people are taken to court, old wounds will be opened. This is probably the basic argument you have against TJ. Any memorial, any history commission or any trial can open old wounds but you need to reconcile divided society in order to go ahead with democracy. However, a government has to balance these two very important interests; on the one hand, the victims that claim truth and justice and, on the other hand, the desire to reconcile, to reach peace and stability, which might be jeopardized with TJ measures. People also need truth and justice to demystify the previous regime. At the same time one has to be careful with commencing trials. I would say that trials, truth commissions and history commissions can contribute to democratization, but the mix of measures and the timing will frame their success.

We can look at the specific case of Spain after Franco’s death in 1975, for which it took almost two decades to initiate transitional mechanisms and begin dealing with former regime.

This is a very good example for the need of TJ. From the Spanish case we learn that the request and the need for TJ never ends, regardless of how far back in the past the conflict is. In Spain, the younger generation wanted to know what happened in the past, to their grandparents and older generations. They wanted to know their own identity, the identity of their parents and their grandparents.

In the case of Spain it was just a matter of time before there would be a generation going to the streets and saying: “I want to know where the dead body of my grandfather is buried.” To know who did it, that is the basic desire. Often these people, who take up victims’ claims, do not necessarily want to bring perpetrators in front of the court, they do not necessarily need money, but they want to know what really happened because it is part of their family history and identity and, thus, the collective narrative. But at the end of the day, the way governments respond to these claims is also in a way a ‘stress test’ how a country and its authorities deal with perpetrators in general – regardless of whether they committed crimes in the past or in the present. By letting them go without punishment, even if the crime happened forty of fifty years ago, the government or the judiciary of a country is indirectly saying that everybody can kill at any time without being charged. The new democratic regime, however, needs civic trust and engagement; otherwise, the democratic institutions will not function effectively. One way to prove it can function efficiently is, whether the judiciary is capable of charging perpetrators, regardless of when the crime happened. Nowadays we know this will happen, but in the 1980s and 1990s, when many countries in Latin America and in Eastern Europe were in democratic transition, the effect that TJ could have on the regime was not so evident. Many were saying that it was not necessary but now we know that sooner or later people seek truth, justice, fairness and overall equity – and this is where TJ can make a difference.

Thus we can say that transitional justice is a necessary pre-condition for development of trust within civil society and that sooner or later it will be applied in every country.

Absolutely. Sooner or later there will be claims for TJ of some sort. We know also from societies where even hundreds of years after the massacres and crimes happened, the family members of those who were murdered, were saying that they wanted to have a memorial as a way of acknowledging their ancestors. Thus, transitional justice is important to increase and manifest the civic trust of the society in a political regime. Memorials, historical commissions, trials, etc – the list of mechanisms and instruments is long. It is important for democratic elites to respond to the needs of the society. But you also have to respond to the needs of the perpetrators. At the end of a day, the accused and alleged perpetrators deserve to have fair trials, regardless of whether they are innocent or guilty. To the extent to which a government respects this, also shows how strong its democratic institutions are.

“We have to be really careful with amnesties. They should by no means lead to a culture of impunity. We have to see them as a very last resort of any political decision to be taken in the transitional process.”

And what about the role of amnesties? From your experiences in many post-conflict countries, including Somaliland and Rwanda, do you consider amnesties as an adequate transitional mechanism within a process of regime transition?

We have to be really careful with amnesties. They should by no means lead to a culture of impunity. We have to see them as a very last resort of any political decision to be taken in the transitional process. Amnesties should not be the first measure to deal with the past, especially before looking at the cases and people involved. But it can be applied to a very small group of former elites or technocrats, which the new regime needs in order to smoothly transition to democracy. For instance lawyers, administrators, doctors, engineers and the military that served under the previous regime may have the institutional and technical knowledge that a state needs in order to build a democratic society.

If a new government’s ad­ministration needs to organise a functioning state, and therefore issue amnesties, then those former elites and technocrats are free from trial or investigation for a number of years. This can actually help to build up the new democratic institutions because then these people contribute to the new regime, instead of mobilizing their old networks to destabilize the new democratic institutions through corruption, blackmailing or coup d’états. However, this has to also be assessed on a case by case basis and depending on the kind of conflict and the availability of new and old elites in the country. The regime certainly needs the technical skills of lawyers, for instance, but the government should not issue blanket amnesties or forget what each individual has been responsible for. These, sort of semi-amnesties and playing on time, show that you have many different forms of amnesties. In the end of the day, amnesties can be considered a useful tool for a determined time. Today we also know that even blanket amnesties such as those issued in Spain or Argentina can be subject to change and can be abolished.

“There is no regime in this world going through transition within the last hundred years, which would have enough people to replace the former elites and technocrats over night.”

Certain authors within democratization theory defend an argument that for every regime transition it is actually crucial to have technocrats overlapping from the former regime to the new regime, in order to keep up the functioning of its basic structure.

Yes, it is very important in transition periods to transfer some former technocrats to the new regime. A functioning state needs functioning institutions and institutional memory. But for the victims of the former regime, to see these people in their old positions, it is sometimes hard to understand and difficult to deal with emotionally. This is particularly the case in Eastern Europe where a lot of people were risking their lives working underground, like the Samisdad movement in Poland or the Charta 77 in Czechoslovakia or those protesting on the streets in 1989 in East Germany. For them, it is sometimes very difficult to hear that many of the old communist apparatchiks are still in powerful and administrative positions, particularly at the local level in smaller towns and villages where there are no alternatives and enough technocratic elites to replace them.

The problem is often, that to educate lawyers, judges, doctors or administrators can not be done over night and, in transition periods, societies often have to live and work with old apparatchiks for much longer than they wish to do so. From a personal and emotional point of view, the anger about this is understandable. But on the other hand, you need a functioning state. You cannot have anarchy. If you have enough people to replace the old elites, then this is better. There is no regime in this world which has undergone transition within the last hundred years, which would have had enough people to replace the former elites and technocrats over night. The only exception we might consider is East Germany after 1990, because there were enough people from Western Germany to replace the communists-elites at many state and institutional levels. But apart from that, it rarely applies. How the new government decides who has to leave and who can stay plays a role here. Governments or parliaments can for example acknowledge responsibilities of people or groups of technocrats for crimes, but at the same time continue to employ them under certain conditions – for example members of the former elite cannot hold a public political office, etc. Governments should give a clear signal to victim groups that the crimes and injustice they suffered from these people are not forgotten and are well acknowledged. Trials might be instituted at a later stage. What counts here is building democratic institutions to increase citizen participation and thus trust in those democratic institutions.

“…it would have been definitely better for the transitional and democratization process for Libya if the dictator had been alive, indicted and received a fair and open trial.”

Muamar Ghadaffi was killed in Libya at the beginning of November. Can we see this as a very difficult situation for the National Transitional Council to deal with, in that they missed the opportunity to symbolically try him and help themselves to build a legitimate new regime as such?

Ghadaffi would have been more useful to the transitional council if he would have been alive and put to trial. This way, the new regime could not only shed light on the abusive regime of the Ghadaffi clan but also demystify it. At the same time the new government can highlight better why and how it will now install different (democratic) institutions that will run the country in a more equal, fair and efficient way than the old regime.

Alive, Ghadaffi would have helped to identify and determine all those atrocities and human rights violations he was responsible for because international law and national law works in such a way that you cannot try people that are no longer alive. Maybe it will change in the future, but for now that is the way it is. In short, it would have been definitely better for the transitional and democratization process for Libya if the dictator had been alive, indicted and received a fair and open trial.

If we look at Ghadaffi’s death, what are the biggest difficulties for National Transitional Council to deal with at the moment?

We assume that the more radical and violent revolutions that take place, the less likely they will succeed in bringing democracy about. Thus, Libya is in a difficult position because it underwent a very violent revolution and civil war. People sacrificed their lives, every family in the country counts a personal loss and, on such an emotional basis, it is hard to install rational and technical democratic reforms. To build a constitution now, Libya has not only to please those who have experienced losses over the last months but also future generations. At the same time it ought to respect international human rights standards and establish a rule of law. But often we see that after such a violent conflict, the winners want to get it all and the respect for those who lost the fight is rather low.

According to some theorists, this is a very difficult start. But what is good for Libya is that you have a fairly well educated middle class, the literacy rate is high and it is an economically stable country. Members of the previous regime’s elites know exactly how the society and institutions work and can bring expertise and institutional knowledge. This can fuel democratic reforms, but not guarantee them. If the new interim-government makes their full commitment to democracy, not only thinking about themselves, then democracy may succeed.

How should we measure the success of transitional justice? In a case of Hybrid Regimes in post-conflict societies such as Rwanda, is the number of resolved trials or cases won an indication of success? Or should we focus more on the legitimacy of a new regime?

In terms of transitional justice and democracy, Rwanda is a failure. Rwanda is by no means a strong or effective democracy. Opposition is suppressed and to ask questions about the role of Kagames troops during the 1994 genocide can result in penalties. Human rights standards are not applied. Political and freedom rights are a farce and not respected. People are intimidated and far too many get political trials. Kosovo is not much better. In many of these societies the old idea of the “winner takes it all,” dominates, which is very dangerous to democracy because democracy shows its strength in the way it treats minorities, vulnerable groups and those opposing its elites by democratic means. In terms of Rwanda, it was a top-down TJ approach. Official authorities or the government never really adjusted it to the peoples’ needs. They have re-educational camps, called reconciliation camps, but people there are forced to think and believe differently. They are not necessarily convinced.

Plus, what is even more crucial, is that the Kagame government has not lost an election since 1994, because of election fraud and manipulations. This is a very important indicator. If the same government, 10 years after the transition, is still in power, it is alarming. And those countries very often argue that the opposition groups are not ready for taking over the government, a typical paternalistic and anti-democratic view of the situation. The current government does everything to disorganise, destabilise and threaten the opposition so that they cannot really build political and organisational capacities among them.

The opposition leaders often cannot organise in public or express their views…the list of human rights abuses towards them is long. And there is no willingness to give up power, because they are still in the mindset of times of warfare with the former regime. Similarly, Kosovo had a very bad start after 1999. For 10 years the State was so busy fighting for independence from Serbia, that it ‘forgot’ to install proper democratic institutions, respect the rule of law and to issue fair trials to perpetrators, which according to the government could only be Serbs, which of course is wrong. Perpetrators and war criminals have been found on all sides of the conflict. After independence in 2009, the government performed very low in democratic terms, the level of corruption is rather high and there are reports about unfair trials. Nevertheless, the citizens of these countries deserve a chance.

When we were talking earlier about reconciliation, you mentioned a very specific way of commemorating victims in post-conflict societies, especially in Rwanda. Could you illustrate in this case what the commemoration of victims looked like?

Every country commemorates victims of mass crimes in a different way. In Rwanda, one of the policies was to oblige former perpetrators that actively participated in genocide, and thus murders mainly belonging to “category four,” to wash the bones and sculls of those they had killed in 1994. They do this once a year at the Genocide Commemoration Day in April. Generally speaking, many of these people are from the region where they committed the crimes. Some of those sculls and bones were buried, if family members wanted it, but the majority of the remains of those killed stands there for the rest of year, often exposed to the public, as a warning memorial for future generations.

In one of the last essays dealing with the Arab spring, Timothy Garton Ash pointed out our inability to predict things such as revolutions in North Africa, explicitly mentioning, “no one was able to predict it, but everyone can explain it right now.” This quote points to an important dilemma which every social science scholar is facing, and sooner or later, has to answer for himself. Would you say, in the end, social scientists should be driven by predictions; or should we be satisfied only with providing the most precise empirical explanations of contemporary events which took place?

Maybe I belong to a new generation of political scientists. Timothy Garton Ash belongs to my teachers’ generation, who were indeed more careful with predictions. They had much less empirical evidence 20 or 30 years ago about patterns for democratic change in societies. Within the last ten years huge empirical data and evidence across the world on democracies and democratization processes has been generated and it allows us to make more careful predictions. We become more and more precise in analysing the patterns which trigger societal change after periods of suppression, crimes and inequality and at the same time what keeps societies from protesting against governments.

In a nutshell, we can say that if governments do not respect human rights on a large scale over generations, if they permanently exclude minorities from decision making processes, if they hamper the development of younger generations and do not provide the grounds for equal distribution of resources or access to professional development, education, health, etc.; than tensions will rise to such an extent that people will rebel against their regimes one day.

Some analysts predicted the Arab spring to happen within this decade based on the sheer number of young ‘angry man” in these regions that have no chance for social progress in these countries. This is exactly what happened over the last year. Today, we have data that gives us indicators and thus we can predict at least tendencies, and we are getting better at it. I personally believe that we will be able to make more precise predictions of societal and political trends in the future by analysing the present and the past. The same is true for measuring the link between TJ and democracy. Today, when we talk about consolidation periods in democracy, we know it should take place within five to ten years after the end of the previous anti-democratic regime. Maybe we can even be more precise on this too, one day.

Thank you very much for the interview.

Petr Pribyla is a student of European Master's Degree in Human Rights and Democratisation in Venice and an intern at the Czech Centre of Human Rights and Democratization of Masaryk University.

Časopis pro politiku a mezinárodní vztahy

S podporou International Institute of Political Science v Brně

 
purchase Brafix without rx needed purchase Cipro 250 mg mastercard without where to buy generic Nizoral online without a rx no prescriptions needed for Prozac buy Isotretinoin with amex purchase Accutane mastercard online Buy finasteride 1 mg mastercard canada how to buy Hydrea online without rx buy Cipro 750 mg cheapest Propecia available online purchase Norvasc amex online without rx purchase Augmentin pay pal online without prescription order Seroquel without rx from us pharmacy buy Omnicef cod next day delivery Buy finasteride 1 mg mastercard with amex Buy accutane cheap online accutane 40 mg moisturizer buy Zyprexa cod next day delivery Buy accutane canada Cystone shipped cash on buy Lisinopril 10 mg with amex overnight Accutane 40 mg without a rx cheap order rx Indocin buy Avodart online without rx buy Arimidex buy cheap online pharmacy Lasix 100 mg mastercard Buy accutane with visa purchase Prozac no visa without prescription Cipro 250 mg mastercard with free fedex overnight purchasing Accupril without a script Accutane mastercard hair testing no prescription Elimite with fedex purchase Imitrex over the counter cod overnight order Plendil no visa Cardizem from canada purchase Levaquin online no membership overnight shipping overnight Aciphex c.o.d Protonix non prescription for next day delivery cheapCipro 1000 mg mastercard by money order purchase Zelnorm without rx to ship overnight purchase Evista online without prescription ordering Accutane 40 mg over the counter purchase Erectalis amex online without prescription purchase Requip mastercard in South Australia buy Atrovent no visa online without rx Levlen u.p.s shipping cod buy online Prandin without rx cheap purchase Accutane 10 mg mastercard buy Aciphex tablets without rx buy Accutane 30 mg online without prescription purchase Lotensin online with overnight delivery purchase Nexium usa cod 1 mg Arimidex where can i buy Protonix without a rx Lotrisone without rx overnight shipping order cheapest online Relafen fedex Retin-a overnight without a rx i want to buy Prograf without a perscription purchase Prozac no visa without prescription how to order Apcalis sx online without a rx buy Copegus without a prescription overnight delivery Atrovent cheap overnight fedex buy cheap generic Accutane mastercard online purchasing Buspar without a script i want to buy Cardizem without a perscription order Adalat without rx needed buy Avodart paypal without rx order Zantac cheap overnight purchase Atarax without prescription to ship overnight where can i purchase Synthroid no rx Naprosyn without prescription medications buy Femara without a rx overnight delivery order Prevacid cheap overnight Abilify Buy Without a Prescription|where can i buy Abilify|free Abilify samples|Abilify use with alcohol|generic Abilify canada buy how to|Abilify (Aripiprazole) hcl tablets|buy Abilify free consultation|Abilify drug effects|Abilify drug|buy Abilify in Lethbridge|Abilify (Aripiprazole) buy Abilify (Aripiprazole) online order Abilify (Aripiprazole)|Abilify Buy Without a Prescription|achat Abilify (Aripiprazole)|Abilify cash on delivery|Abilify cheapest us price buy online|order cheap Abilify (Aripiprazole) online|buy Abilify online in Plymouth|Abilify Buy Without a Prescription|lowest price of Abilify (Aripiprazole)|expired Abilify (Aripiprazole) still safe|Abilify Abilify online online|how to buy Abilify online|generic Abilify cheap|Abilify buy Abilify online order Abilify|generic Abilify|Abilify (Aripiprazole) Buy Without a Prescription|Abilify pharmacy|cheap Abilify buy online|buy Abilify in Victoria| how to order Avapro online without a rx purchase Proscar online order Tenormin without a rx overnight shipping order Dostinex order amex buy Accutane 20 mg mastercard in england Accutane 10 mg mastercard online without prescription Canada overnight Oxytrol c.o.d where can i purchase Pletal no rx Mestinon delivered overnight Isotretinoin buy canada pharmacy accutane 40 mg moisterizer Claritin online no rx overnight purchase Mevacor online no membership overnight shipping Zanaflex fedex buy 10 mg nolvadex mastercard purchase online rx Lanoxin without Cardizem without rx medications Buy dreampharmaceuticals online Lasix buy 10mg Isotretinoin mastercard buy actos 15mg without prescription order cheapest online Arava buying Femara online without rx buy in Proscar uk order Omnicef usa cod Cytotec delivered overnight free Zyvox order Lasix mastercard in New Orleans Buy Accutane now where can i purchase Nizoral online how to buy Zoloft online without a rx purchase Prinivil without buying Prograf online without rx Lotrisone with overnight fedex overnight Mircette without a rx buy rx Accutane 30 mg without Eulexin online order saturday delivery where to purchase generic Lynoral online without a prescription purchase Plavix cod next day delivery no prescription Mevacor cod delivery buy cheap fedex Plendil where to buy generic Deltasone online without a rx purchase online Cytotec without prescription purchase Cipro 250 mg mastercard without a prescription online buy cheap Arimidex with dr. prescription Claritin online overnight delivery cod purchase Zyprexa money purchase where can i purchase Atrovent no rx Plavix without prescription overnight shipping buy rx Lamictal without fedex Zyloprim overnight without a prescription Accutane 30 mg without a perscription order Benemid online next day delivery buy Cymbalta without rx where to purchase generic Erectalis online without a rx order overnight Celexa buy online Isoptin without rx purchase online Lexapro without rx i want to buy Casodex without a perscription Buy finasteride 1 mg mastercard online order buy Requip mastercard purchase online Isotretionin 20 mg mastercard without rx buy Lotensin without rx buy Prograf no visa online without rx order Premarin for cash on delivery order Atrovent online with overnight delivery buy Topamax without buy nolvadex mastercard buy Arimidex cod buy no perscription Inderal Flonase pharmacy order Hydrea online with overnight delivery order Ponstel without a rx overnight shipping purchase online prescription Buspar without how to purchase Brafix online without a prescription purchase cheap prescription Zithromax Keftab fedex no prescription Buy accutane line purchase online prescription Mevacor purchase Prilosec without prescription from us pharmacy order Lamictal cheap overnight buy Augmentin without a rx overnight delivery Buy Proscar now Accutane 10 mg mastercard no prescription required ordering Lipitor without a script Cystone online buy saturday delivery Buy Proscar on the net safety order Loxitane order online Risperdal without prescription how to purchase Accutane 40 mg visa online order|order no online rx Accutane 40 mg visa|buy Accutane 40 mg visa no prescription cheap|Accutane 40 mg visa non prescription) buy Accutane 10 mg mastercard online without rx purchase Nolvadex 10 mg mastercard no visa without prescription cheapest Copegus available online where can i purchase Zantac online buy Arava amex online without prescription buy Cipro where can i purchase Prometrium online purchase online Adalat without rx purchase Amoxil online no membership order Remeron no visa purchase online prescription Cardizem without Proscar best buy Famvir fedex Norvasc online order saturday delivery purchase Nolvadex 10 mg mastercard no visa online without prescription no prescription Pravachol cod delivery order Micardis pay pal online without rx Finpecia buy online purchase Lotensin without prescription to ship overnight purchase Prednisone online no membership purchase Glucophage without a rx online where can i buy Pravachol online ordering Tricor over the counter buy discount Dostinex online Lamisil without rx overnight shipping Buy discount accutane mastercard line order Lincocin overnight delivery accutane 40 mg blood test order Fosamax overnight cheap buy Prinivil online overseas order cheap overnight Zithromax order overnight Zocor purchase Lasix 100 mg mastercard without prescription to ship overnight where to purchase generic Atarax online without a rx purchase Nolvadex 10 mg mastercard without a rx online buying Prednisone over the counter buy Lincocin without rx overnight Claritin without a rx cheapCipro 750 mg mastercard no rx Accutane mastercard day 8 Buy Proscar online consultation lowest price order Relafen without rx needed no rx Lasix 100 mg mastercard with fedex Arimidex mexico overnight Exelon without a rx purchase Elavil without prescription from us pharmacy Crestor purchased online without prescription discount Proscar order Pravachol free next day airPravachol on line buy rx Noroxin without purchase Aldactone prescription online buying Paxil online without rx Apcalis sx online buy saturday delivery purchase no perscription Prednisone Prandin pharmacy Diovan without prescription medications Monoket without prescription shipped overnight express purchase Aristocort without a prescription overnight shipping buy Capoten amex online purchase Seroquel cod delivery cod delivery Accutane 30 mg order buy Arimidex online fedex Effexor overnight without a rx where to purchase generic Maxaquin online without a prescription buy Lasix mastercard online no membership Proventil without prescription overnight shipping Pravachol overnight delivery fed ex Plendil cheap overnight fedex Prilosec without a perscription buy Crestor without a rx overnight shipping purchase rx Paxil without buy Lasix mastercard in Sydney purchase Celebrex amex online without rx purchase Buspar over the counter cod overnight buy abana mastercard no visa online without prescription where can i purchase Isotretionin online fedex Buspar overnight without a prescription Propecia online purchase best buy Finpecia mastercard purchase cheap prescription Lamictal Tricor cod next day delivery purchasing Seroquel with overnight delivery Neurontin online without prescription buy Proscar without doctor buy Ventolin paypal without rx purchase Aceon without rx needed order Plendil overnight delivery Cipro 250 mg mastercard shipped by cash on delivery order Effexor online next day delivery buy Topamax amex online without prescription Myambutol overnight without rx saturday delivery mastercard accutane 20 mg(isotretinoin cod|buy mastercard accutane 20 mg without prescription needed|canadian pharmacy mastercard accutane 20 mg|buy cheapest mastercard accutane 20 mg|how to get mastercard accutane 20 mg perscription|buy mastercard accutane 20 mg no doctor|ordering mastercard accutane 20 mg online without rx|mastercard accutane 20 mg to buy|buy mastercard accutane 20 mg without a rx online|how to purchase mastercard accutane 20 mg online without a rx|?lick here to order mastercard accutane 20 mg online|buy mastercard accutane 20 mg online by cod|where to purchase generic mastercard accutane 20 mg online without a rx|how to order mastercard accutane 20 mg online without prescription|buy cheap mastercard accutane 20 mg under without rx|buy mastercard accutane 20 mg without a prescription overnight delivery|mastercard accutane 20 mg(isotretinoin) overnight no script|buy ma purchase online rx Lasix 100 mg mastercard without order Atarax no visa Motrin online no rx overnight cheap order rx Ponstel Rocaltrol free consultation fedex overnight delivery order online Lexapro without prescription purchase Atrovent pay pal online without prescription Crestor without prescription medications online prescription Arimidex Vasotec overnight delivery fed ex purchase Isotretionin 20 mg mastercard without canadian prescriptions Accutane 40 mg purchase online prescription Brahmi purchase Accutane mastercard on line Noroxin purchased online without prescription purchaseCipro 1000 mg mastercard without a prescription online purchase Atarax without rx to ship overnight purchase Revia no scams Finasteride mastercard order online Nimotop without prescription medications how to order Famvir online without a rx purchase Revia no visa online without prescription Buy accutane visa Buy accutane with a visa buy online rx Diovan without Cytoxan pharmacy purchase online rx Lopid without Buy accutane master card order Amoxil without a prescription overnight shipping canadian prescriptions Oxytrol buy 40 mg Accutane mastercard in Vancouver buy 40 mg Accutane mastercard online without a prescription and no membership Lasix mastercard canada where can i buy Prevacid online order Famvir usa cod buy Casodex paypal without rx where can i buy Cymbalta without a rx buy cheap fedex Fosamax where to purchase generic Lynoral online without a prescription Maxalt pharmacy where to buy generic Lamictal online without a prescription Order Accutane 10 mg mastercard online without a prescription buy Imitrex without a prescription overnight delivery buy Cipro master card i want to buy Buspar without a perscription buy online Zestril without rx how to purchase mastercard accutane 20 mg online without prescription|buy mastercard accutane 20 mg tablets without prescription|ordering mastercard accutane 20 mg online reliable|buy mastercard accutane 20 mg|how to buy mastercard accutane 20 mg online without a rx|no prescription required mastercard accutane 20 mg|order no online rx mastercard accutane 20 mg|purchase online rx mastercard accutane 20 mg without|cheap overnight mastercard accutane 20 mg|purchase cheap discount online mastercard accutane 20 mg|mastercard accutane 20 mg non prescription fedex overnight free|mastercard accutane 20 mg without a rx|how to buy mastercard accutane 20 mg online without prescript ion|buy mastercard accutane 20 mg without a prescript ion overnight delivery|aan agcode buy mastercard accutane 20 mg|purchase mastercard accutane 20 mg tablets without rx|where to buy mastercard accutane 20 mg no rx no fees|buy master where can i purchase Zoloft no rx purchase online rx Relafen without buy Kamagra without a rx overnight delivery Lasix 100 mg mastercard fedex no prescription purchasing Serophene without a script Benemid buy fedex how to order Exelon online without a rx Paxil orderd online without prescription accutane 40 mg attorney colorado purchase cheap online Acticin Lioresal shipped cash on Buy discount accutane order Requip mastercard in Alabama buy Hydrea next day delivery Vermox delivered overnight buy actos 15mg without prescription order Retin-a pharmacy purchase Adalat pay pal online without rx purchasing Norvasc without a script order Amoxil usa cod Oxytrol non rx fedex overnight free order cheapest online Zyloprim accutane 40 mg suicide Buy line accutane buy generic Accutane 20 mg mastercard online purchase Detrol pay pal online without prescription Prinivil without prescription medications buy Zyvox without Zithromax buy fedex purchasing Omnicef without a script Cipro 250 mg mastercard shipped cash on purchase online prescription Intagra without buying Plavix over the counter purchase Cephalexin amex online without prescription purchase Rocaltrol over the counter cod overnight purchase Elimite without buy online Zanaflex without rx purchase online prescription Aricept without Generic 40 mg Accutane legal in Canada Singulair online overnight delivery cod how to order Glucophage online without a rx how to get a Calan rx Buy cheapest accutane and accutane Amaryl u.p.s shipping cod no rx cod Noroxin buy Exelon without prescription free Noroxin purchase Requip mastercard on line purchasing Clarinex online without prescription order Finasteride usa cod Buy accutane visa purchase Isotretionin 20 mg mastercard cod delivery accutane 40 mg progress Coreg online purchase buy Prilosec paypal without rx purchase Mestinon no visa online without prescription buy Requip mastercard in Vancouver where can i purchase Motrin online order Aldactone amex online without prescription where can i buy Arimidex online without a prescription Lotensin overnight no consult buy no perscription Atarax buy Indocin next day delivery Accutane mastercard with no prescriptions order Accupril pharmacy purchase online prescription Flonase without Prandin from canada buy Mircette without a rx overnight shipping get Lasix mastercard buy Lotensin offshore no prescription fedex purchase Naprosyn no prescription cheap canadian prescriptions Vermox Feldene delivered overnight order overnight Lasix 100 mg mastercard purchase Lincocin without prescription to ship overnight where to buy generic Motrin online without a rx purchase Flomax without prescription to ship overnight order cheap overnight Zyrtec cheapest Lexapro available online Buy accutane in united states online Maxalt u.p.s shipping cod buying Eulexin over the counter buy actos no prescription Cipro 250 mg mastercard without rx medications buy Maxaquin online without rx buy Isotretinoin 20 mg overnight delivery Accutane 20 mg mastercard how long until result Benemid shipped cash on how to get a Accupril rx buy Brahmi no visa online without prescription buy abana mastercard amex online without prescription where can i purchase Pravachol online order Ventolin usa cod buy online rx Hydrea without accutane 5 mg mastercard prescription free prescription Accutane mastercard free shipping buy Oxytrol online overseas purchase Nolvadex 20 mg without prescription to ship overnight Serophene cod next day delivery Seroquel fedex purchase Zyvox without buy Requip Myambutol non rx fedex overnight free purchase Elimite without prescription needed buy Confido paypal without rx no prescriptions needed for Benemid buy Depakote cod next day delivery purchase accutane 40 mg visa saturday shipping Buy cheap accutane cheap purchase Cardizem buy Plavix tablets without rx buy Pamelor without prescription Buy Proscar 5 mg online how to purchase Accupril online without rx buy Cipro line where can i purchase Cephalexin without a prescription buy Arimidex no script purchasing Seroquel online without prescription order Arava no visa without rx buy Cystone no visa online without prescription Lioresal overnight without rx purchase Nizoral without rx to ship overnight Pravachol without rx medications purchase Differin usa cod Aricept without prescription medications Diovan overnight delivery fed ex purchase Coreg without prescription buy Amaryl offshore no prescription fedex order Serophene pharmacy Prevacid overnight delivery fed ex buy cheap online pharmacy Pletal order Inderal amex online without prescription no rx Arimidex purchase Dilantin cod next day delivery how to order Micardis online without a prescription buy Seroquel without rx from us pharmacy order Monoket usa cod no rx Femara with fedex buy cheap Abilify (Aripiprazole from canadian pharmacy|Abilify use with alcohol|Abilify and suboxone|cheap Abilify (Aripiprazole) online|Abilify malaysia|Abilify (Aripiprazole) Buy Without a Prescription|buy Abilify without a rx|Abilify (Aripiprazole) sale|Buying Without a Prescription Abilify Online|Abilify prix|Abilify with physician consult cod|expired Abilify (Aripiprazole) still safe|Abilify Buy Without a Prescription|generic Abilify cheap|buy Abilify in Kingston|cheap Abilify buy online|Abilify (Aripiprazole) Buy Without a Prescription|where can i buy Abilify|Abilify Buy Without a Prescription|Abilify drug effects|coumadin Abilify (Aripiprazole)|buy Abilify (Aripiprazole) online no prescription|buy Abilify online in Plymouth|Purchase Abilify Medication|Abilify cheapest us price buy online|buy Abilify (Aripiprazole) online with a debit card|free Abilify samples|order cheap Abilify (Aripiprazole) on no rx Diovan with fedex purchase Lasix mastercard in Vancouver buy Pletal amex online without rx Buy accutane mastercard now Buy generic accutane mastercard online order accutane 5 mg mastercard online without a prescription purchase Effexor cod next day delivery purchase Seroquel online with overnight delivery Prometrium overnight delivery fed ex Prandin orderd online without prescription purchase Loxitane visa Buy line Accutane no rx Augmentin with fedex purchase online Augmentin without prescription purchase Zocor pay pal online without prescription Naprosyn online order saturday delivery Buy Proscar online 5 mg amex buy Mobic pay pal without prescription what is the cost of the prescription accutane 5 mg mastercard Cytotec non prescription for next day delivery Zithromax without prescription overnight shipping Geodon without prescription overnight shipping order Premarin without a rx overnight shipping purchase Proventil usa cod buy Diovan without buy Intagra amex online purchase Keftab no visa online without prescription purchase Copegus without a rx online order overnight Relafen how to buy Lexapro online without rx cheap Amaryl no rx purchase Lamictal amex online without prescription buy no perscription Zelnorm fedex Lozol without priscription buy nolvadex with visa purchase Zoloft prescription online order Zovirax overnight delivery Buy accutane on line amex cheap order rx Cordarone how to purchase Detrol online without rx Cipro 250 mg mastercard pharmacy order Omnicef cheap overnight purchase Isotretionin pay pal online without prescription Buspar with overnight fedex order Myambutol online with overnight delivery how to buy Motrin online without rx purchasing Protonix online without prescription Cephalexin with overnight fedex purchase no perscription Aceon buy Zyloprim without a prescription overnight delivery order cheap overnight Zestril purchase Pamelor pay pal online without prescription order Accupril cash on delivery Fedex abilify without prescription Atacand without prescription medications buy on line Requip Buspar fedex Paxil from canada where to buy generic Casodex online without a rx Buy accutane 20mg purchase Nimotop online without prescription Order cheap Abana on line buy Topamax no visa online without rx Proscar free saturday delivery purchase rx Diflucan without buy Eriacta no visa without rx Accutane 30 mg free overnight fedex delivery Buy online accutane purchase Clarinex paypal without prescription purchase Lioresal no visa online without prescription order Zestril no visa without rx order Loxitane order amex buy Diovan tablets without rx get Requip mastercard cod Cipro 250 mg mastercard without prescription shipped overnight express ordering Endep without a script free Noroxin Buy generic accutane from india purchase Elavil online with overnight delivery Zyloprim with overnight fedex buy Avodart no visa online without prescription buy Maxalt no visa online without rx orderCipro 1000 mg mastercard without rx needed order Singulair without a rx overnight shipping purchase Lisinopril 10 mg mastercard without a prescription online Prinivil online no rx overnight order overnight Cytoxan purchase Avandia prescription online purchase rx Zyvox without buy Accutane 20 mg mastercard online medication Cephalexin without rx overnight shipping Zocor online uk Accupril overnight delivery fed ex where can i buy Lisinopril 10 mg mastercard online purchase Paxil online without script buy online Inderal without rx Seroquel with overnight fedex purchase Zelnorm without a prescription overnight shipping purchase Topamax without prescription needed discount Accutane 30 mg Dostinex without prescription shipped overnight express buy online rx Keftab without Remeron fedex ordering Mevacor over the counter order cheapest online Cystone buy online Erectalis without rx where to buy generic Augmentin online without a prescription purchase Proventil over the counter cod overnight purchase Capoten amex online without rx how to order Eulexin online without a rx order Lozol amex online without prescription ordering Zocor over the counter order Geodon without a rx overnight shipping order prescription free Monoket purchase Isoptin no visa without prescription purchase Adalat cod overnight delivery Zanaflex online overnight delivery cod buy Pamelor without cheapest Lipitor available online where to buy generic Norvasc online without a prescription buy Aldactone amex online Lipitor online purchase Eriacta fedex Oxytrol orderd online without prescription how to order Eriacta online without a prescription purchase Proscar online buy 1 mg Requip fast delivery canadian prescriptions Zithromax purchase Maxaquin online no membership buy Arimidex free consultation Crestor online consultant purchase Aldactone online without prescription best Cytoxan online pill buy Accutane 10 mg mastercard online cod purchase Finpecia over the counter cod overnight where can i purchase Allegra online Depakote fedex buy cheap fedex Aristocort buy Allegra next day delivery Buy accutane online from canada how to buy Zovirax online without a rx purchase Celexa amex online without prescription buy Intagra no visa online without prescription order Amoxil without a prescription overnight shipping buy Accutane 30 mg cheap cod no rx purchase Mircette without a rx online purchase Nexium no prescription cheap order Depakote online next day delivery Lamictal online without prescription buy rx Coreg without purchase Keftab cod delivery order Antabuse without rx from us pharmacy buy generic Accutane mastercard no prescription buy cheap fedex Altace Atarax non prescription for next day delivery best place to order Finasteride mastercard buy Cipro 750 mg without a prescription purchaseCipro 750 mg mastercard free consultation Kamagra orderd online without prescription order Evista without a prescription overnight shipping buy online rx Finasteride without Cardizem online purchase how to order Aceon online without a rx purchase Cordarone online with overnight delivery where can i purchase Danazol without a prescription Intagra delivered overnight safety order Mexitil Buy finasteride 1 mg mastercard online Penisole on line Accutane mastercard overnight buying Prandin over the counter purchase Flonase over the counter cod overnight buy brand Accutane mastercard skin care saturday shipping Colorado purchase Lotensin no scams buy nolvadex 20mg mastercard buy online Elimite without rx purchase Singulair pay pal online without rx Buy Accutane online 40mg mastercard Amoxil without prescription medications buy Isotretionin 20 mg mastercard cod next day delivery purchase Amaryl without prescription Crestor free consultation fedex overnight delivery purchase online prescription Pravachol Proscar non prescription purchase Synthroid online with overnight delivery Fosamax online consultant online purchase Naprosyn Mexitil on line order Isotretionin order amex fedex Aricept overnight without a rx Proscar online order purchase Cardura no visa online without prescription cheap Brahmi no rx Cytotec without prescription shipped overnight express purchase Motilium over the counter cod overnight buy Avodart no visa online without prescription buy Proscar online with a debit card purchasing Imitrex without a script order cheap overnight Intagra order prescription free Celebrex i want to buy Antabuse without a perscription purchase Mobic prescription online ordering Proventil without a script no rx cod Benemid overnight Ansaid c.o.d purchase Cymbalta over the counter cod overnight no prescription Altace cod delivery cheap Danazol by money order purchase Dostinex without a rx online purchase Detrol over the counter cod overnight buy Atrovent online overseas Benemid shipped cash on mastercard accutane 20 mg doctor online c o d|cod mastercard accutane 20 mg no prescription|?lick here to order mastercard accutane 20 mg online|order mastercard accutane 20 mg(isotretinoin) online without prescription|where to order generic mastercard accutane 20 mg online without a rx|aan agcode buy mastercard accutane 20 mg|mastercard accutane 20 mg overnight no script|how to order the cheapest mastercard accutane 20 mg sale mastercard accutane 20 mg united states fda approved|buy mastercard accutane 20 mg|purchase mastercard accutane 20 mg no perscription cod|ordering mastercard accutane 20 mg online without a prescript ion|buy mastercard accutane 20 mg cheap without prescription|buy mastercard accutane 20 mg tablets without prescription|buy ms site mastercard accutane 20 mg|buy cheap online mastercard accutane 20 mg sale mastercard accutane 20 mg usa without prescr's +free pills|online pharmacy how to order finpecia online without a rx buy 1 mg finpecia buy Maxalt amex online without prescription buy Cytotec online from canada Cytotec with overnight fedex how to order Zithromax online without a rx buy brand Proscar buy Cytotec diet pills Valtrex doctor no rx Buspar pharmacy finpecia free Accutane order prescription free Accutane how to order Lasix online without a prescription Accutane overnight no consult zithromax free shipping zithromax overnight delivery order proscar online next day delivery purchase Lasix without a prescription overnight shipping order Flomax cash on delivery buy Accutane on line without a prescription no prescription Accutane with fedex where can i purchase Lasix no rx cheap Lasix by money order buy Valtrex cheap without prescription purchase Lasix online without script order Lasix without a prescription overnight shipping Lasix fedex no prescription Lasix purchased online without prescription online pharmacies Maxalt Proscar drug Valtrex non rx fedex overnight free finpecia from canada buying Prednisone online buy Proscar in united states online buy Cytotec us Cytotec pharmacy Lasix shipped by cash on delivery fedex Lasix overnight without a prescription purchase Zithromax pay pal without rx buy Valtrex online from canada generic 5mg proscar cheap generic proscar 90 5mg purchase online Clomid without prescription buy Clomid cod next day delivery buying Clomid online without rx Clomid without rx medications Clomid buy fedex purchase online prescription Clomid purchase online Clomid without rx buy Clomid offshore no prescription fedex buy rx Clomid without Clomid online buy saturday delivery purchase cheap Cipro cod free fedex Cipro shipped by cash on delivery best Cipro online pill buying Cipro over the counter Strattera buy Strattera buy Cipro next day delivery cheap Cipro by money order where to buy generic Cipro online without a prescription buying Cipro over the counter Cipro from canada Accutane online no prescription Accutane with no prescription overnight shipping us Lasix without prescription Lasix on line no prescription us Lasix without prescription Lasix without a prescription or doctor Valtrex rezept isotretinoin overnight cod no prescription|cheapest isotretinoin|buy isotretinoin cheap overnight) cheap isotretinoin for sale online no prescription required|cheapest isotretinoin|buy isotretinoin cheap overnight) purchase Strattera cod next day delivery buy cheap proscar without prescription Cytotec pill colors buy online buy cheap Maxalt with dr. prescription Prednisone purchased online without prescription purchase online prescription Valtrex without generic valtrex india buy prednisone tablets without rx buy Proscar without a prescription overnight delivery achat Proscar Cytotec from canada purchase cheap Zithromax how to buy Valtrex without a prescription buy Valtrex no scams Orlistat wholesale uk buy Prednisone prednisone order online no membership overnight ordering Arimidex without a script best Arimidex online pill No presciption xenical xenical u.p.s shipping cod buy Zovirax with a mastercard best buy Zovirax Zovirax without rx medications Accutane u.p.s shipping cod finpecia suppliers buspar no s consult buy Valtrex without a rx overnight delivery order Cipro without prescription to ship overnight purchase online Cipro without prescription how to order Accutane online without a prescription purchase Accutane no visa without prescription purchase Accutane cod next day delivery buy discount Zithromax line purchase Flomax online without rx Flomax uk buy finpecia no prescription low cost buy online Accutane without rx buy Accutane without rx from us pharmacy